Well, in my opinion, he was indeed a refreshing change for SS. It's nice to see someone actually give the critiques asked for. He didn't go overboard "critiqueing", but for the most part he seemed to be honest. He does seem to stick to the "C" subs. He commented me before on "L only"... didn't critique, but didn't fluff the hell out of me either, what's more fair than that?
I have to admit, I heard a couple subs that were pretty poorly done that he praised (must have been a friend he didn't want to hurt their feelings, or perhaps he just didn't notice?)... but there's a bit of softie in all of us I guess.
Atleast he doesn't seem to give bad reviews where not wanted, nor do any snipe ranking... Probably best the he doesn't sing, that way people can take him more seriously when he comments.
I figured he'd be right back with a new name. (valid email address too I'll wager)
... Actually (read before typing replies Charm, Lol) I just saw someone mention that he has sang here, I must have missed that sub;)