That particular track is identical to the
SBI one, and also appears on
Sunfly vol. 73. It has become my favourite arrangement of the song, and I have sung it both here and on T.I.K. (
here's a link to my rendition on the Showcase if anyone is interested!)
My guess is that maybe Wilson Pickett did a live version that sounded like that. [It's like Just Tracks/Pocket Songs version of the Neil Diamond version of
I'm a believer - quite different from the 1967 studio version, it's of a live performance from the 80s (I think) and is the best karaoke track of that song out there in my opinion]. By the way, Sunfly also put out another version of
"In the midnight hour" with artist style labelled as Pickett but in reality is the Commitments version. The best karaoke in my experience that's closest to the original Pickett recording is the
DK one.
I used to hate tracks like that which are that far removed from the original recording. I turned that on its head by purchasing these wacky tracks, learning them and approach the song from a completely different angle. With
Midnight Hour I ad libbed a lot of the lyrics towards the end. The backing track being so unlike the original song made it easier to make "my" own unique version rather than a bad wannabe WP clone. I would advise you to do the same with yours and have fun with it! I did something similar with SBI's version of
I Can See Clearly Now "as performed by Johnny Nash" (yeah right!!)