American Pie, great song but I wouldn't want to hear it more than maybe once every few months
Picture, good song but time for it to Vaya Con Dios for awhile
PBTDL, one of my least favorites, by the time they are at 1rst base I'm wishing it were the 7th inning stretch
Celine & Whitney, I like some of Celine, & Whitney is ok if the singer isn't being too diva-ish
Don't Stop Believing, rarely hear it
Sweet Caroline, great song, a bit oversung
Total Eclipse, ", " " "
Janis Joplin, there are a lot of singers that don't know what a harpoon is and have never worn a dirty red bandana, let alone a clean one, who try this song and then think they have sung it better than Janis but I suspect no one has
Frank Sinatra, there are so many great Sinatra songs, why do we always only just get to hear That's Life and My Way?
Elvis, I like hearing Blue Suede Shoes, Fool Such as I, and Love Me
Patsy Cline, I'll go crazy if I hear that song again
Marvin, a little overdone but nice to hear sometimes
Edmund Fitzgerald, I've only heard it a few times in karaoke
Love Shack, good song but a few times a year is good enough (I learned to drive in a Chrysler Town & Country station wagon that was as big as a whale, so I like the lyrics)
Friends in Low Places, an awesome song with great melody and lyrics, but can be oversung
Turn the Page, great song but don't want to hear it every week
Hotel California, seems to be mostly sung by girls, less often by guys?
Crazy On You, I'd say the singer at Karen's show gave it a good effort (and it got better as the song progressed)--that's a tough song! My favorite heart song is Dreamboat Annie
Freebird, I've sung it a few times but kind of avoid it because of the long outro, I don't think it's over sung though, maybe it is in Alabama. There was a guy in my 8th grade class that wanted Freebird to be in our graduation ceremony.
That said, I have to remember what it was like when I first started singing karaoke. I'm sure I sang a lot of songs that people had heard many times before and I unwittingly thought I was giving the bar "fresh material".
Part of karaoke IMHO is learning to be patient as a listener. You only get to sing a few times. The rest of the night you hear songs you like, good singers, singers who aren't as accomplished, and also you hear songs that have been oversung. The skilled KJ can try and direct singers to new material, which I think is good, but there will always be the karaoke standards that get sung a lot. Patience is a virtue!