tigger wrote:
OK, I finally have a place to ask the questions about vibratos that I have wondered for so long.
1. Why does it seem like any given singer with a strong vibrato is always labelled as really really good, even when the rest of their singing isn't that great? Has anyone else noticed this?
2. Do most people fake it or is it natural? Is there a way to tell? Should it matter? Should I try and fake it? I'm afraid people will be able to tell!
3. How the hell does one develop it? Lessons, time, or genetics?
First a quote from the LaRousse Encyclopedia of Music:
vibrato. An effect, once an ornament but now a standard part of tone production, whereby a singer or instrumentalist imparts a throbbing quality to a note by oscillating between it and a pitch slightly below. With singers, the louder the note, the more pronounced, usually, the vibrato—and the oscillation can become so wide that the hearer may be left in doubt as to just which note is being aimed for. If the technique is applied, as it often is, to a fairly rapid passage, the result is quite unnerving and totally unmusical (except, apparently, in the opera house).
1. Don't know. Not all singers I've heard have vibrato. I listened to some Louis Armstrong recently and he has some vibrato but only on longer notes which is the case with many of the 'better' singers. BTW, by better singers I mean those that stand the test of time - not 'popular' singers.
2. It is natural for some people (Hi, Luly!) and others fake it. Does it matter? Yes and no. It can be faked by moving the jaw slightly (or induced this way) or by moving the mic back and force to create a fluctuation in the pitch (sort of a mini doppler effect) and volume. Sometimes faked is near impossible to tell from the real thing and other times it's obvious they're faking or trying for an 'effect' which is unnerving.
3. If you 'want' vibratto I'd consider talking with a vocal coach first to improve overall (not that you sing poorly - just that a vocal coach can show areas to improve and specific exercises to work with). As I said before, some people can 'induce' vibrato by moving the jaw slightly when they're holding a long note. Remember, vibrato isn't normally noticed on short notes, only on notes that are held for longer periods of time.
BTW, with some singers you'll hear vibrato come in as they are nearing the end of their air supply and they'll use vibrato to lengthen the note.
Hope this helps! BTW, sorry I haven't subbed lately... I owe a certain person a requested sub (sweet home chicago!) but this hayfever is kicking my butt!